Department of Justice uses Hobby Lobby case to argue dismissal of suit from Christian college

Samantha Reinis
South Carolina Campus Correspondent

Total Shares
This is the CRO SBAR

  • Wheaton College, an Christian school in Illinois, sued the Department of Health and Human Services over the department's contraception mandate.
  • U.S. Solicitor General Donald Verrilli says the case should be dropped because Hobby Lobby's court victory relied on religious accommodations that Wheaton says violate its rights.
  • The Justice Department used the Hobby Lobby ruling as basis for dismissing a case brought against it by Wheaton College, in a letter to the U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday.

    Wheaton College in Illinois is suing the Department of Health and Human Services “against the administration’s controversial HHS mandate, which forces the evangelical liberal arts institution to violate its religious beliefs or pay ruinous fines,” according to the university’s website.

    U.S. Solicitor General Donald Verrilli argues that the case should be dropped, however, as “[Wheaton College] seeks...to prevent the government from alleviating the resulting harm to its employees and students by ensuring that others provide or arrange the coverage instead.”

    Essentially, the college believes that allowing emergency contraceptives to be provided in any way to its student population, even through third party healthcare plans, infringes on its religious rights under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA).

    Wheaton argues that governmental accommodations for religious institutions are also in violation of the RFRA. Verilli disagrees.

    “Nothing in RFRA supports such a sweeping claim,” Verrilli says.

    Indeed, the Solicitor General says that Hobby Lobby’s victory over the federal government relied on such accommodations.

    “The decision in Hobby Lobby rested on the premise that these accommodations ‘achieve all of the Government’s aims’ underlying the preventive-health services coverage requirement ‘while providing greater respect for religious liberty,’” Verrilli wrote.

    The filing by Wheaton is the first response to the Burwell v. Hobby Lobby decision that was announced on Monday.

    Wheaton College did not respond to a request for comment from Campus Reform in time for publication.

    Via the Star Tribune.

    Follow the author of this article on Twitter: @samantha_reinis



    Samantha Reinis

    Samantha Reinis

    South Carolina Campus Correspondent

    As a Campus Correspondent,  Sam covers liberal bias and abuse at South Carolina's colleges and universities. She is currently a senior studying Political Science with a minor in Philosophy at Clemson University. Samantha is currently the Editor in Chief of Clemson University’s conservative publication, The Tiger Town Observer.

    More By Samantha Reinis


    LATEST TWEETS

    Logan Fleckenstein
    @LoganRFleck - 35 min ago

    @CalebBonham @campusreform Will do. I hope to work with you and campus reform in the future.

    Caleb Bonham
    @CalebBonham - 38 min ago

    @LoganRFleck @campusreform thanks for contributing to my presentation - stay in touch

    Logan Fleckenstein
    @LoganRFleck - 56 min ago

    @CalebBonham of @campusreform did a presentation at the YAL convention in Michigan and it was truly motivating.

    DR. ?
    @phi_delenda - 3 hours ago

    App State dorm bulletin board shames 'privileged' students http://t.co/shbuA9mR4U via @campusreform #diversity #tolerance

    Jeron Capone Siegel
    @SiegelCapone - 4 hours ago

    Killz Shoot A Nigguh Promo ft. SiegelCapone, Creo…: http://t.co/Hso2DE6PHH house arrest coming soon @campusreform @sadtrips @BOBNComp

    dorothy tyler
    @dhtyler - 5 hours ago

    Dem representative thinks climate scientists are getting funds from fossil fuel interests http://t.co/iD4p807ic2 via @campusreform

    dorothy tyler
    @dhtyler - 5 hours ago

    EXCLUSIVE: California profs 'unequivocally' endorse American flag ban http://t.co/6qhCprvYH3 via @campusreform

    dorothy tyler
    @dhtyler - 5 hours ago

    Bard students demand mandatory social justice training and seminars http://t.co/yxYhVSa7dm via @campusreform

    Latest 30 Articles