VIDEO: Millennials say America was ‘never that great’

Cabot Phillips
Media Director

  • New York Governor Andrew Cuomo has come under fire for declaring that America "was never that great," but perhaps he was just echoing the views of his fellow New Yorkers.
  • Most of the young people I spoke with in New York City unabashedly sided with Cuomo, and several maligned American Exceptionalism in far stronger terms than Cuomo dared to use.
  • New York Governor Andrew Cuomo found himself in hot water after claiming that President Trump’s “Make America Great Again” slogan is inaccurate because it implies that America was great to start with. 

    “We’re not going to make America great again; it was never that great,” Cuomo contemptuously remarked.

    "I personally wasn’t taught American Exceptionalism because I went to a very forward thinking liberal school."   

    [RELATED: Cuomo recruits public scholarship recipients for campaign ad]

    Wanting to know what young Americans thought of these comments, I went to Washington Square Park in New York City to talk with Governor Cuomo’s constituents about those comments. 

    When asked if there was ever a time in America’s history when we were great, the majority of the people I spoke with made it clear: they were siding with Governor Cuomo. 

    “I don’t believe America has been great for all folks, ever. Even today,” said one respondent, while another added simply, “I would have to agree with Governor Cuomo.”

    One person elaborated on their reasoning for saying America was never great, saying, “The idea that there was this once great America is pointing towards this false sense of nationalism…What, it’s talking about white America? Yeah, it’s not great.”

    Another respondent cited similar points, declaring that “America has been great…for straight white men.”

    [RELATED: Wisconsin College Dems leader: 'I f---ing hate white men']

    Wondering if this thought process stemmed from what was being taught in the classroom, I followed up by asking if they’d ever been taught American Exceptionalism in school. 

    Just one person said it was a concept they’d been taught in class. 

    “I’ve never heard of it before,” conceded one, while another explained that “I personally wasn’t taught American Exceptionalism because I went to a very forward thinking liberal school…”

    What else did they have to say? Did anyone say America is great? Watch the full video to find out!


    Follow the author of this article on Twitter: @cabot_phillips





    Cabot Phillips

    Cabot Phillips

    Media Director
    Cabot Phillips is the Media Director for Campus Reform. Prior to joining Campus Reform he spent time working on numerous campaigns—most recently as the Digital Grassroots Director for Marco Rubio’s Presidential bid. Phillips is also a YouTube Partner, creating and starring in numerous videos which have amassed over 70 million views across varying online platforms.  In 2016, Phillips was named to Red Alert Politics "30 Under 30" list of the nation's most influential young conservatives.
    More By Cabot Phillips

    20 Articles by Cabot Phillips