Former Valdosta student settles First Amendment lawsuit for $900K

  • Hayden Barnes made a satirical collage about Valdosta State University building two parking garages.
  • Former Valdosta President Ronald Zaccari labeled his post a "threatening document" and declared him a "clear and present danger."
  • Barnes, Zaccari, and Valdosta State have now settled for $900K.

Valdosta State University (VSU) student was expelled over eight years ago and has just now winning his battle for free speech on campus.

Hayden Barnes was a student at Valdosta State University in 2007 when he was expelled because he expressed unfavorable opinions about the VSU administration using $30 million in student fees to build two parking garages on campus.

Barnes had concerns that the building project was bad for the environment and that it was being fueled by faculty self-interest. He took to Facebook to express his personal opinion by posting a satirical collage of the parking garage, former president Zaccari, and pro-environmentalist pictures in an attempt to highlight his personal opinion on the controversial campus issue.

The now-former President Ronald Zaccari labeled Barnes’s post a “threatening document” and stated that the student was a “clear and present danger.”

With help from the Foundation for Individual Rights and Education (FIRE), Barnes filed a civil rights lawsuit in 2008 against Zaccari and VSU administrators, as well as the Board of Regents of the Georgia University System.

In 2012, the Eleventh Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals held that Zaccari could be held personally liable for directly violating Barnes’s right to due process. The court held that because Zaccari ignored Barnes’s “constitutional right to notice and a hearing before being removed from VSU,” Zaccari was not allowed to use his status as a state employee against liability in the lawsuit.

In late July, more than eight years after Barnes’s expulsion and the start of litigation, the two sides settled to the tune of $900,000.

According to FIRE President and CEO Greg Lukianoff, Barnes has endured one of the worst abuses to a student’s rights that the organization has ever seen. Stating that, “would-be censors at public universities nationwide have 900,000 new reasons to respect the free speech and due process rights of their students.”

Follow the author of this article on Twitter: @LettyBurgin

Get exclusive access to breaking CampusReform stories as they happen. Sign up below and we'll keep you in the loop.
 Weekly Digest

 Daily Emails

Letty Burgin
Letty Burgin | Florida Campus Correspondent

As a Campus Correspondent, Letty reveals liberal bias on university campuses across the state of Florida. Letty is a student at Florida State University and is earning her B.A. in Political Science. 

16 Articles by Letty Burgin