Archivists lose track of own emails, blame media outlet

Neetu Chandak
New York Campus Correspondent

  • The Society of American Archivists appears to need more practice keeping track of its records after it erroneously claimed that Campus Reform lied about contacting its members.
  • SAA President Tanya Zanish-Belcher told members of an internal forum that Campus Reform had not contacted any SAA members or staff prior to publishing an article about anti-"whiteness" panels at the group's recent conference.
  • Screenshots, however, show that five separate individuals received requests for comment more than 24 hours before the original article was published.
  • The Society of American Archivists appears to need more practice keeping track of its records after it erroneously claimed that Campus Reform lied about contacting its members.

    In a post on an internal forum last week, SAA President Tanya Zanish-Belcher referenced “significant concerns” among the group’s members over a Campus Reform article reporting on a recent SAA conference that featured two panels outlining critical evaluations of “whiteness.”

    "A recent post on the Campus Reform website has raised significant concerns among our members..."   

    [RELATED: Panelists look to ‘decenter whiteness’ in university archives]

    “Notwithstanding the author’s claim that she had ‘reached out to SAA, as well as the professors involved in the panels,’ no member of the SAA Council or staff was contacted for comment,” Zanish-Belcher informed colleagues indignantly.

    As evidenced by numerous screenshots, however, Campus Reform did, in fact, request comment from each of the panelists, as well as SAA Education Consultant Solveig De Sutter.

    Additionally, professors Michelle Caswell, Jamie Lee, Ricardo Punzalon and doctoral student Marika Ciphor were contacted with requests for additional insights into the “Identifying and Dismantling White Supremacy in Archives” panel discussion in which they participated.

    Like the email to De Sutter, each of the panelists was contacted with identical requests for comment at around 10:30 a.m. (Eastern) on July 31—more than 24 hours before the article’s publication.

    The discussion surrounding the Campus Reform article was shut down on August 9 by SAA Executive Director Nancy Beaumont, who felt that the “discussion was becoming redundant and circular” due to “unprofessional” and “intimidating language” used by several posters.

    Going forward, the forum will be “actively moderated” until the SAA is able to review the role and future of the listserv at its November meeting.

    Follow Campus Reform on Twitter: @CampusReform





    Neetu Chandak

    Neetu Chandak

    New York Campus Correspondent

    Neetu is a New York Campus Correspondent, and reports on liberal bias and abuse on her campus and around the state for Campus Reform. Neetu is a Communications major at Cornell University, where she works with Network for Enlightened Women.

    More By Neetu Chandak

    Latest 20 Articles