Christian College wins court battle against contraceptive mandate

  • A federal judge recently ruled against the Obama-era contraceptive coverage mandate, granting Wheaton College a permanent injunction from enforcement of the mandate.
  • The court ruled that forcing the school to provide contraceptive coverage would cause "irreparable harm to its ability to practice its religious beliefs."

A federal district court ended a lengthy legal battle over the Obama-era contraceptive mandate last week, ruling that the government cannot force Wheaton College to provide birth control.

According to the decision, the judge ruled that the school “is entitled to a permanent injunction” after carefully reviewing the briefs submitted by all parties.

"The government should never have tried to force us to provide drugs and services against our faith, and we are pleased by the resolution of our case."   

“Wheaton has demonstrated, and Defendants now concede, that enforcement of the contraceptive mandate against Wheaton would violate Wheaton’s rights under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act,” the judge observed. “Wheaton will suffer irreparable harm to its ability to practice its religious beliefs, harm that is the direct result of Defendants’ conduct, unless Defendants are enjoined from further interfering with Wheaton’s practice of its religion.”

[RELATED: Notre Dame changes mind again, will cover contraceptives]

“We are grateful to God that the court recognized Wheaton’s religious identity and protected our ability to affirm the sanctity of human life,” college President Philip Ryken said in a statement. “The government should never have tried to force us to provide drugs and services against our faith, and we are pleased by the resolution of our case.”

According to the college, last week’s ruling offers the first permanent protection from the mandate since the Supreme Court’s Zubik v. Burwell ruling in 2016, and will further protect the academic institution “from any current or future version of the mandate.”

The college also noted that the complex contraceptive mandate made it to the Supreme Court five times, with the Court ruling in favor of religious institutions in every case. 

A new HSS rule that is said to offer protection to religious groups, however, was halted by judges in Pennsylvania and California last year, further complicating the legal challenges faced by many religious organizations around the country.

[RELATED: Notre Dame health plan to stop paying for birth control]

Diana Verm, one of the attorneys representing the school through the non-profit law firm Becket, told CBN News that the federal government cannot act above constitutional law and the civil rights doctrine. 

"The government is not above the law--that's why we have civil rights laws," she argued. "Wheaton should never have had to go to court to protect its rights in the first place."

Follow this author on Facebook: Nikita Vladimirov and Twitter: @nikvofficial

Get exclusive access to breaking CampusReform stories as they happen. Sign up below and we'll keep you in the loop.
 Weekly Digest

 Daily Emails

Nikita Vladimirov
Nikita Vladimirov | Correspondents Editor

Nikita Vladimirov is a Correspondents Editor for Campus Reform. Prior to joining Campus Reform, he wrote for The Hill, where he extensively covered the latest political developments in U.S. and around the world. A 2016 national finalist for the Society of Professional Journalists' "Mark of Excellence Award," Nikita now resides in Washington D.C. and contributes to the Washington Examiner. His work has appeared on the front pages of The Drudge Report and The Hill, and has been featured by leading media organizations including Fox News, MSN, Real Clear Defense and many others.

20 Articles by Nikita Vladimirov