Is the Constitution 'exclusionary'? Students react (VIDEO)

  • Syracuse University denied registered club status to a conservative group in part because of its strict adherence to the U.S. Constitution.
  • The university did so because it said the Constitution could be "exclusionary" to some students.
  • Campus Reform asked students on the New York State campus if they agreed.

In February 2019, Syracuse University created a stir when it denied registered club status to a Young Americans for Freedom chapter on campus. 

In a statement explaining the decision, the university cited, in part, the group's strict adherence to the U.S. Constitution, saying, “requiring students to agree in the superiority of the U.S. Constitution is exclusionary to international students and other individuals.” Wanting to know if students at the university agree with that position, Campus Reform Correspondent and Syracuse student Justine Murray went to ask. 

“To say the Constitution excludes certain people is sort of absurd."   

After explaining the situation to student participants, Justine asked simply, “is the Constitution exclusionary?”

Some of their responses may surprise you. 


[RELATED: Syracuse U: U.S. Constitution is 'exclusionary' to some students]

“I think it’s exclusionary not just to students, but to people all across the United States,” one student said, while another added, “I think that there’s definitely elements of the Constitution that are exclusionary to some students.”

“I think it could be read as that. I’m not up to date with my reading of the U.S. Constitution, but I could see how the University could take that view of it," the student continued.

One student who agreed with the university said that  “although it’s been amended, there are still lots of laws in place that still discriminate… and they use the Constitution as justification for that.”  

But when asked to elaborate, she admitted, “I’m sorry, I feel like that doesn’t really make sense. I thought about it. I can write a paper on it, but right now I didn’t expect you to go into detail.” 

There were, however, students who disagreed with the university's opinion.

[RELATED: Under pressure, UVA agrees to recognize conservative group]

One student agreed that the Constitution was exclusionary when it was made, but said "it’s still the basis on which we stand as a country. [The university] may disagree with it, but they shouldn’t be able to restrict any clubs from stating that in their mission statement."

“To say the Constitution excludes certain people is sort of absurd,” another student told Campus Reform.

One student conceded the university is “maybe trying to fit us into a mold.” When asked what that mold might be, she said “I do believe this campus is very liberal. I think a lot of the things they do and programs they hold, things they allow reinforce those views.”

Follow the authors of this article on Twitter: @Justine_Brooke and @Cabot_Phillips

Get exclusive access to breaking CampusReform stories as they happen. Sign up below and we'll keep you in the loop.
 Weekly Digest

 Daily Emails

Justine Brooke Murray and Cabot Phillips
Justine Murray | New York Campus Correspondent

Justine Brooke Murray is a New York Campus Correspondent, reporting on liberal bias and abuse for Campus Reform. She is a Junior at the Maxwell School at Syracuse University, majoring in Political Science. Justine is the Founding Chair of Syracuse University’s Young Americans for Freedom chapter and the former Chief of Staff for the New York Federation of College Republicans. She stood with President Trump at the White House when he signed the Campus Free Speech Executive Order in March 2019. Justine has appeared as a guest on numerous new shows, including FOX News Digital, OANN, the Joe Pags Show and the Dennis Prager show. She is a student ambassador for Prager University where she works on the video production committee. Justine is a fellow for CAMERA on Campus. She also is the reigning Miss Northern Highlands in the Miss America Organization, and uses her title to further promote free speech on college campuses. She will be competing for Miss New Jersey.

18 Articles by Justine Murray