Feminist Profs: selfies perpetuate classic 'gender roles'

Toni Airaksinen
New Jersey Senior Campus Correspondent

  • The professors analyzed 233 female selfies posted online after the first University of Georgia home football game of 2013.
  • They found that "formal wear, soft and flowy dresses, a significant amount of jewelry," bright red lipstick, and white teeth characterize the "southern lady."
  • A group of feminist professors recently discovered that Instagram selfies taken by women in college can reinforce “traditional gender roles.”

    In a study led by Mardi Schmeichel, a University of Georgia (UGA) professor specializing in “feminist theory,” a team of professors analyzed 233 selfies that were posted in 2013 within 24 hours of the first UGA football home game of the semester.

    "[T]he southern lady images that circulate in these selfies reinscribe a traditional femininity organized around/on a binary."   

    Schmeichel and her team analyzed these selfies to see if they represented “the idealized symbol of the southern lady,” which they note is an aesthetic trope that “has had significant and enduring consequences on notions of femininity in the South.”

    This symbol of the southern lady, they argue, is typified by students’ formal wear, soft and flowy dresses, a significant amount of jewelry, and clothes that emphasize “feminine curves without revealing what might be considered ‘too much’ skin.”

    Bright red lipstick and white teeth are also considered emblematic of this southern aesthetic, Schmeichel argues.

    [RELATED: Feminist profs: Citations perpetuate 'white heteromasculinity']

    After analyzing selfies posted in the time surrounding the first 2013 UGA home game, Schmeichel found that 25 percent of women who posted photos embody this harmful aesthetic.

    “The clothing, makeup, posing and editing used in the southern lady images work together to achieve a hyperfeminine gender performance that differs significantly from the images of women in the other selfies,” Schmeichel laments.

    “In the southern lady images, attention to a traditionally gendered performance has been emphasized,” Schmeichel writes, lamenting that “the southern lady images that circulate in these selfies reinscribe a traditional femininity organized around/on a binary.”

    She also notes that students’ embodiment of femininity can be troubling.

    [RELATED: Prof frets that female students don't feel oppressed enough]

    “The celebration of traditional femininity has been is [sic] a vexing concern for some feminists, who have interpreted it as a rolling back of hard-won progress to eliminate women’s association with these rigidly gendered and often marginalized subject positions.”

    “If we are committed to destabilizing gender binaries and working toward a world in which bodies, and images of them, are not traded as capital, then there must be some attention paid to ways in which women’s [Instagram] practices and behaviors can get in the way of these goals,” Schmeichel concludes.

    Campus Reform reached out to Schmeichel and her team for comment, but did not receive a response in time for publication.

    Follow the author of this article on Twitter: @Toni_Airaksinen





    Toni Airaksinen

    Toni Airaksinen

    New Jersey Senior Campus Correspondent
    Toni Airaksinen is a New Jersey based Correspondent for Campus Reform, and reports liberal bias and abuse for Campus Reform. Her reporting focuses on campus First Amendment, Title IX, Equal Opportunity, and due process issues, and her stories have been profiled by numerous outlets including Fox News, The New York Post, PBS News, and The Washington Examiner.
    More By Toni Airaksinen

    Campus Profiles

    Latest 20 Articles