University pays $10k to settle free speech lawsuit

  • Southern Illinois University, Edwardsville has agreed to pay $10,000 to settle a First Amendment lawsuit filed by the school's College Republicans chapter.
  • In September, a campus police officer told the students they could not hold a "free speech ball" event on campus because it was "scaring" students, adding that they needed a permit because the state university is not a "public place."

Southern Illinois University, Edwardsville has settled a lawsuit with the College Republicans, agreeing to pay the group’s attorney fees and revise its unconstitutional speech policies.

According to NBC affiliate KSDK, the university will pay $10,000 for attorney fees and has already eliminated its speech zone after the College Republicans, with help from the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), challenged the constitutionality of the school’s free speech policy in October.

'This is not considered like a public place. Right now, we’re going to have to put the ball away."   

SIUE maintains, however, that it only agreed to the settlement in order to avoid “the much great cost of protracted federal litigation.”

[RELATED: Cops tell activists their ‘free speech ball’ ‘scared’ students]

“The University is pleased to reach an agreement, but some clarity is necessary regarding the University’s policies and procedures,” the university said in a statement provided to KSDK. “SIUE has always supported the notion that every student should be able to speak freely and peacefully, regardless of their political viewpoint and without fear of being punished.”

The university also added that it is “constantly reviewing and modifying its policies and procedures, and would have been happy to talk with the College Republicans, the Alliance Defending Freedom, or others, had they brought their concerns to our attention prior to filing the lawsuit.”

According to the lawsuit, the university restricted its free speech zone to “less than 0.0013% of the entire SIUE campus” and did not “provide any alternative locations for student speech outside the Speech Zone.”

“Defendants’ Speech Policies and their practice of limiting students’ and student organizations’ expressive activities to a single Speech Zone at SIUE facially violates the First Amendment because it prohibits students and student organizations from engaging in speech in public areas of the campus other than the limited area of the Speech Zone,” the lawsuit argued.

As previously reported by Campus Reform, conservative students at the university were confronted in September by a campus police officer, who told them that their free speech ball was “scaring” classmates and that they had failed to secure the proper permission to hold the demonstration.

[RELATED: GVSU settles with conservatives, gives up ‘speech zones’]

When the students objected that they were simply exercising their First Amendment right to express themselves in a public place, the officer rejected their contention, arguing that the state university campus is not public.

“This is not considered like a public place. Right now, we’re going to have to put the ball away,” one officer told the student activists at the time, further noting that the ball “is freaking a lot of people out.”

Despite settling the suit, however, SIUE continues to dispute the students’ primary allegations, insisting that it has never restricted student speech to a free speech zone nor required a permit or other form of administrative approval for free speech.

“SIUE has not limited student free speech activities to less than one percent of the SIUE campus and has demonstrated that fact many times,” the school’s statement declared, adding that “SIUE did not agree to pay damages, because there were none.”

Follow this author on Facebook: Nikita Vladimirov and Twitter: @nikvofficial

Get exclusive access to breaking CampusReform stories as they happen. Sign up below and we'll keep you in the loop.
 Weekly Digest

 Daily Emails

Nikita Vladimirov
Nikita Vladimirov | Correspondents Editor

Nikita Vladimirov is a Correspondents Editor for Campus Reform. Prior to joining Campus Reform, he wrote for The Hill, where he extensively covered the latest political developments in U.S. and around the world. A 2016 national finalist for the Society of Professional Journalists' "Mark of Excellence Award," Nikita now resides in Washington D.C. and contributes to the Washington Examiner. His work has appeared on the front pages of The Drudge Report and The Hill, and has been featured by leading media organizations including Fox News, MSN, Real Clear Defense and many others.

20 Articles by Nikita Vladimirov