Oberlin College sued for MILLIONS after attacking 'racist' local bakery

  • Oberlin College has been ordered to pay $11 million in damages to a local bakery and the family that owns it.
  • The lawsuit stems from the college and its administrators allegedly defaming the shop over a 2016 incident.

Oberlin College has to pay $11 million in damages after a bakery won a lawsuit alleging the school defamed or otherwise libeled the family-owned shop.

The lawsuit, filed by the Gibson’s Bakery shop in November 2016, was settled this week when an Ohio jury ordered Oberlin College to pay $11 million to the bakery after being accused of libelous behavior. Following an attempt to shoplift from the local bakery, the lawsuit alleged that Oberlin employees -- and the institution itself -- spread defamatory information against the bakery for allegedly racist behavior.

“[Gibson’s] is a RACIST establishment with a LONG ACCOUNT of RACIAL PROFILING and DISCRIMINATION.”   

In Nov. 2016, an Oberlin student, Jonathan Aladin, was caught attempting to steal wine from the bakery. Two other individuals, according to the lawsuit, were also arrested and accused of misdemeanor assault during the same altercation.

In response to the arrests, protests and boycotts against Gibson’s bakery ensued with protesters accusing the store of being racist as Aladin is a minority. Reportedly, numerous employees of Oberlin attended these protests, passing out allegedly libelous flyers which read: “[Gibson’s] is a RACIST establishment with a LONG ACCOUNT of RACIAL PROFILING and DISCRIMINATION.” 

In addition to accusing the bakery of racist behavior, the flyer called for an economic boycott as well.

WATCH: Campus Reform speaks with Cornell law professor William Jacobson about Oberlin College: 

 

[RELATED: Clemson restaurant gets grilled over 'offensive' chicken sandwich sign]

“Today we urge you to shop elsewhere in light of a particularly heinous event involving the owners of this establishment and local law enforcement."

The flyer included a description of the incident, claiming that Aladin “was apprehended and choked” by a Gibson’s employee and subsequently “chased and tackled” prior to being arrested by local police.

In response to the accusations of sustained actions of discrimination, the Oberlin Police Department conducted its own investigation into the bakery’s history, finding that of the 40 adults arrested for shoplifting at Gibson’s in the past five years, only six were black. 

Aladin went on to plead guilty to a second-degree misdemeanor charge after the felony robbery charge was dismissed. Aladin and the other two individuals arrested during the attempted theft gave statements during their respective sentencing hearings back in 2016.

“The clerk was within his legal rights to detain me,” Aladin wrote. “And I regret presenting a fake ID in an attempt to obtain alcohol. This unfortunate incident was triggered by my attempt to purchase alcohol. I believe the employees of Gibson's actions were not racially motivated. They were merely trying to prevent an underage sale.”

According to the lawsuit, Oberlin College has participated in several libelous and defamatory actions against the bakery including demanding a service contract between the two parties be canceled and continuing to display statements accusing Gibson’s of “racial profiling and discriminatory treatment of students and residents alike” in the student union building on campus.

The lawsuit also alleges that Oberlin college paid for a limo service to transport Aladin, free of charge, to meet with a “high profile criminal defense lawyer.” 

The lawsuit claims that several Oberlin college administrators and faculty members publicly disparaged the bakery and used college resources to promulgate libelous information. One unnamed Oberlin administrator, the associate dean of Academic Affairs, has been accused of using Oberlin resources to print copies of the flyer.

[RELATED: Oberlin students seek to socialize dining halls]

Meredith Raimondo, Oberlin’s current vice president and dean of students who is named as a defendant in the lawsuit, is accused of distributing the flyer to individuals both on and off campus.

Raimondo also met with David Gibson, the owner of the bakery, to discuss an agreement between the two parties for the bakery to call Raimondo when an Oberlin student is caught stealing rather than report the incident to the police or pursue charges. Raimondo’s offer was denied. 

The Oberlin vice president is accused of personally demanding the Oberlin College director of dining services cease engaging with a food service company that had contracts with Gibson’s. Raimondo’s actions caused the third-party food company to cancel its contract with Gibson’s. This decision was later reversed and Gibson’s Bakery is currently back under contract with the company.

According to the Chronicle-Telegram, the jury awarded $2.2 million to the bakery itself, $5.8 million to the bakery owner, David Gibson, and an additional $3 million to his son, Allyn Gibson.

The jury supported both counts of libel against the college and Raimondo. The jury also held the college responsible for the intentional infliction of emotional distress with regard to the treatment of Allyn Gibson, but only found Oberlin College, and not Raimondo, responsible for inflicting emotional distress against David Gibson. 

Raimondo, but not Oberlin, was also found by the jury to be responsible for interfering with Gibson’s Bakery business relationships.

[RELATED: Lawsuit accuses Oberlin of slandering local bakery as racist]

“All [the Gibsons] ever asked from the beginning, from Oberlin College, was to use its power and influence and might to tell the truth, and that letter never came,” the lead attorney for the Gibson family said, following the jury’s decision. “But the jury sent the letter that was louder and more visible and more public. I think the Gibson family is grateful for that and grateful for the jury to have the courage to be able to send a letter that no one else would send for the last almost three years.”

While Oberlin College has yet to make an official public comment regarding the jury’s decision, the institution sent an email to members of its alumni association stating its disappointment with the verdict, as reported by the Chronicle-Telegram.

“Neither Oberlin College nor Dean Meredith Raimondo defamed a local business or its owners, and they never endorsed statements made by others. Rather, the College and Dr. Raimondo worked to ensure that students’ freedom of speech was protected and that the student demonstrations were safe and lawful, and they attempted to help the plaintiffs repair any harm caused by the student protests.”

Peter Wood, president of the National Association of Scholars, told Campus Reform that he has followed this case from the beginning, and said that "Oberlin administrators have a long record of inciting Oberlin students to take stands on 'social justice' issues," adding that "students are primed to exaggerate claims of racism, sexism, and other alleged aggression. " 

"A handful of self-agitated students tried to make something out of nothing," Wood continued. "Oberlin administrators stepped in to assist them,  ideologically and logistically. Oberlin didn't count on real people fighting back. The Gibson family had a powerful story to tell. Oberlin College had only supercilious attitude, which it put on display in its court pleadings, and which it continued to display in its letter to alumni."

Wood called for the college's administration to be "held to account" for "creating the climate" in which this incident occurred.

Follow the author of this article on Twitter: @Grace_Gotcha



STAY INFORMED
Get exclusive access to breaking CampusReform stories as they happen. Sign up below and we'll keep you in the loop.
 Weekly Digest

 Daily Emails

Grace Gottschling
Alliance Defending Freedom | Alliance Defending Freedom

Alliance Defending Freedom is an alliance-building, non-profit legal organization that advocates for the right of people to freely live out their faith.

12 Articles by Alliance Defending Freedom

  • Unsafe Space: The glaring intolerance of Stanford activists

    What happened when two conservatives arrived at an open meeting on prison divestment to contribute their perspectives? They were thrown out, of course.

    Amy Shen Oct 20, 2017 - 3:40 PM EDT
  • How students can help advance freedom on their campuses

    The first line of defense against these violations of constitutional principles is the student body...

    Casey Mattox Oct 10, 2017 - 10:35 AM EDT
  • How does your state measure up on student free speech?

    Universities are regulating what students may say, when and where they can say it, and even who will speak for them.

    Casey Mattox Sep 15, 2017 - 2:18 PM EDT
  • Lumberjacks in Northern Arizona sure are touchy these days

    "The college campus is a giant unsafe space for independent thinkers[.]"

    James Gottry May 08, 2017 - 10:29 AM EDT
  • UMD prez: Trump wants to 'make America white and Christian again'

    UMD’s president is doubling down on his post-election anti-Trump rhetoric, but says students should wait until Trump assumes office to protest his policies.

    Tyler Arnold Nov 21, 2016 - 2:51 PM EDT
  • Clemson admin offers recusal after students question relation to protest leader

    Several Clemson students got a hostile reception Thursday when they started asking questions about a possible conflict of interest in the school’s investigation of a racial bias incident.

    Peter Fricke and Anthony Gockowski Apr 23, 2016 - 12:00 PM EDT
  • Students react to SCOTUS gay marriage ruling

    Student advocates on the stairs of the Supreme Court responded to today’s close 5-4 decision which made same-sex marriage legal in all fifty states.

    Mariana Barillas Jun 26, 2015 - 3:58 PM EDT
  • Penn State frat suspended after cops uncover Facebook page of passed out, nude girls at parties

    One of the fraternity’s Facebook pages, called “Covert Business Operations,” had already been taken down after a female found a topless photo of herself on the page and threatened to take action. The second private page, “2.0,” was then created and remained open and active throughout the police investigation with almost 150 members.

    Kaitlyn Schallhorn Mar 19, 2015 - 12:15 PM EDT
  • VIDEO: University removes wrecking ball sculpture after students ride it naked like Miley Cyrus

    Hundreds of students protested at Michigan’s Grand Valley State University on Tuesday night after administrators removed a swinging sculpture that resembles a wrecking ball.

    Josiah Ryan Sep 18, 2013 - 9:59 AM EDT
  • UCLA student government looks to ban term ‘illegal immigrant’

    The undergraduate student government at the University of California-Los Angeles (UCLA) unanimously passed a resolution Tuesday calling for the end of the use of the phrase “illegal immigrant,” saying it violates human rights guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.

    Katherine Timpf Sep 02, 2013 - 2:35 PM EDT
  • FL Professor Wants Communist Revolution, Says Occupy "Not Radical Enough"



    A Florida professor has been captured on film advocating for a communist revolution and lamenting that the Occupy movement is not radical enough.

    Jamil Khader, an English professor at Stetson University, told his students that communism and a stronger state are needed to thwart "predatory capitalism." In a lecture titled "Is Lenin Good for the Occupy Wall Street Movement?", Khader explained that such a revolution would not start on its own:

    "If Lenin is to be repeated--or the idea of communism as I explained it before--then the national liberation movements in the global south should retroactively be considered one of those causal nodes around which a revolutionary act is formed today...There can be no waiting for the right moment of a revolution to mature on its own and explode. But under certain conditions, it is legitimate--even advisable--to catalyze and force the revolution to come into existence."

    He went on to attack the free enterprise system, stating that the role of the post-colonial state is to protect its subjects from capitalism.

    "If you let it be like that," he said. "capitalism and corporations are simply going to extort more juice from these areas--leaving nothing basically there. The only way to roll it back is to have a stronger state...a dictatorship of the proletariat if it ever happens."

    Khader did not limit his broadsides to capitalism. He periodically took shots at conservative commentator Glenn Beck throughout the discussion, mocking Beck as "insane" and his dire warnings as "sensational rhetoric."

    This is not the first time that Khader, a Palestinian Arab, has dabbled in controversy. He is notoriously anti-Israel, and has publicly accused that republic of apartheid and genocide. When Stetson's Hillel group invited IDF troops to campus for the purpose of teaching students traditional Israeli song and dance, Khader objected--even going so far as to send a bad-tempered letter to the students involved. He has also signed off on boycotts of Israeli businesses.

    Nicolas Tomboulides Dec 03, 2012 - 3:27 PM EDT
  • UPenn offers new queer bioethics course

    The University of Pennsylvania has introduced “Queer Bioethics” as an academic discipline under the Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy in the Perelman School of Medicine.

    The program was created by Lance Wahlert an associate in the Master of Bioethics Program, and Autumn Fiester, director of graduate studies in the Department of Medical Ethics and Health Policy.

    The two teamed up in 2010 to create a queer bioethics course and have diligently worked to expand the program.  According to the Daily Pennsylvanian (DP), the project has more than 300 scholars from 25 countries with a journal dedicated to the subject in the works.

    Wahlert and Fiester plan to integrate more “queer content” into preexisting bioethics courses at Penn.

    An example of a few of the issues listed on the website site which the project will focus on include “recognition of LGBT patient surrogates,” “blood donation standards for same-sex sexually active individuals,” “the dilemmas of gay youth studies,” and “hetero-biased sex education.”

    “The test of whether queer bioethics is sustained and whether it succeeds will not be the popping up of literal departments,” Fiester told the DP. “It will be the proliferation of deep and profound scholarship and work.”

    University of Pennsylvania administrators did not respond to requests for comment to LI’s Campus Reform.

    Source: The Daily Pennsylvanian.

    Timothy Dionisopoulos Nov 13, 2012 - 5:02 PM EDT