Clemson evicts man for praying outside ‘free speech zone’

Caleb Ecarma
South Carolina Campus Correspondent

  • Clemson University administrator Shawn Jones demanded that a local man who was praying with students leave campus last Thursday because he was not in a designated “free speech zone.”
  • Clemson maintains that university policy requires non-students to pre-register on-campus activities outside of designated areas, but students protest that the entire campus should be open to free speech.
  • Clemson University administrator Shawn Jones demanded that a local man who was praying with students leave campus last Thursday because he was not in a designated “free speech zone.”

    Jones, Clemson’s assistant director for client services, cited the Clemson University Facility Usage Policy as justification for removing Robbie Roberts for praying while sitting next to a sign with the word “prayer” on it. The usage policy states that non-students are restricted to certain campus areas for their full right to free speech.

    “I did not think it was legal for them to remove a non-student from campus simply for communicating with students.”   

    In a Young America’s Foundation (YAF) video documenting the incident, Jones tells graduate student Kyra Palange, who recorded the confrontation after praying with Roberts, that non-students are only permitted to exercise their liberties in designated "free speech zones."

    “This is not a designated free speech area,” Jones informed them.

    “You mean there are free speech areas on campus and that the entire campus is not a free speech area?” Palange then asked.

    [RELATED: Students petition Clemson to eliminate speech restrictions]

    Jones confirmed that characterization, and also called their prayers “solicitation,” despite there being no material or monetary exchange of goods and services involved.

    In an interview with Campus Reform, Palange said she was extremely surprised by the fact that Clemson would kick a man off campus for praying in a non free speech zone, arguing that the entire campus should be a free speech zone.

    “As a public and publicly funded university, I did not think Clemson would even have free speech zones,” she remarked. “I did not think it was legal for them to remove a non-student from campus simply for communicating with students.”

    William Turton, a Clemson student and chairman of the university’s YAF chapter, told Campus Reform that the administration’s claim of solicitation was unreasonable.

    “This is a public space on a public university, so the idea that non-students aren’t allowed free speech on certain areas of campus is unreasonable,” Turton remarked.

    “It’s a stretch to say that a man praying is the same as someone setting up shop and selling stuff on campus,” he added, observing that “[Roberts] wasn’t going out and running up to students and asking them to pray with him, the man was not being disruptive in anyway at all.”

    [RELATED: Clemson students worry 'banana banner' will lead to free speech setbacks]

    Clemson Vice President for University Relations Mark Land, however, insisted that the policy only applies to non-students, saying any student praying alone would have been allowed to continue peacefully.

    “Those individuals or groups not affiliated with the university are asked to follow a simple procedure to register their activity with the university so that it can be directed to an appropriate location, such as one of the university’s designated free speech zones,” he explained in a statement to Campus Reform. “Individuals and groups affiliated with the university are not limited to free speech zones when they wish to exercise their rights to expression.”

    Land also noted that the sign set up by Roberts constituted “solicitation to join a gathering” and thus violated the university’s policies, adding that “there was no intent whatsoever to ban or limit prayer on campus.”

    [RELATED: Clemson used banana incident to advance liberal agenda, emails show]

    Roberts told Campus Reform that he initially intended to cooperate with the administration but said his attitude towards the situation has “radically changed” over the past couple of days.

    He went on to explain that the place where he was sitting was “not a building,” “not a restricted area,” but “basically a park,” calling it “one of the least possible restricted places as far as any kind of theoretical restrictions on freedom of speech” goes.

    “The notion that they say that is a non-reservable space? They just made it up,” he added, visibly frustrated with university’s arbitrary speech zone designations.

    Campus Reform reached out to Jones for comment but he did not respond in time for publication.

    NOTE: Campus Reform investigative reporter Anthony Gockowski also contributed to this story.

    Follow the author of this article on Twitter: @calebecarma





    Caleb Ecarma

    Caleb Ecarma

    South Carolina Campus Correspondent

    Caleb Ecarma is a former South Carolina Campus Correspondent, and and reports liberal bias on campus for Campus Reform. He is a sophomore at North Greenville University, and a Digital Media major. In addition to his work for Campus Reform, he writes for Hypeline News and is the Managing Editor for his university's newspaper.

    More By Caleb Ecarma

    Latest 20 Articles