Study contradicts claims that people can be 'fat but fit'

Toni Airaksinen
New York Campus Correspondent

  • A recent study contradicts many of the claims made by advocates of "fat acceptance," debunking the notion that it is possible to be "fat but fit."
  • Many professors have argued that eliminating "weightism" is more important than encouraging obese people to lose weight, but a new study of 520,000 people found that "being healthy overweight is not true."
  • A recent study contradicts many of the claims made by advocates of "fat acceptance," debunking the notion that it is possible to be "fat but fit."

    Rebecca Puhl, a professor of Family Studies at the University of Connecticut, told The New York Times that fat-shaming has numerous negative consequences for fat people, including “increased risk of weight gain” and “maladaptive eating patterns.”

    "It's another brick in the wall of evidence that being healthy overweight is not true."   

    [RELATED: ‘Fat-shaming’ by doctors is ‘physically harmful,’ prof says]

    “There are very visible people in society making comments about people’s physical appearance in very inappropriate ways,” Puhl complained, asking, “Where are the voices saying that this is not acceptable?”

    While many professors have recently come out in support of the fat-acceptance movement, often by arguing for eliminating weight-bias instead of promoting healthy eating, new research has come out confirming that obesity is indeed a health risk.

    Most recently, Camille Lassale, a professor at the University College London, published the results of a study of 520,000 people in the European Heart Journal—the largest study to date on the impact of obesity on heart health.

    “Even if you are classified as metabolically healthy, (excess weight) was associated with an increased risk of heart disease," Lassale told CNN. "It's another brick in the wall of evidence that being healthy overweight is not true.”

    [RELATED: ‘Fat Studies’ course deems ‘weightism’ a ‘social justice issue’]

    "This reinforces the fact that obesity in itself is a risk factor," Lassale reiterated later in the interview. "Every effort should be made by health professionals to advise on lifestyle changes regardless of these metabolic factors."

    The study disproves the widespread notion in the fat-acceptance community that one can be “fat but fit,” as the study found that overweight and obese people had a significantly higher “hazard” risk than those in the normal weight range.

    “Irrespective of metabolic health, overweight and obese people had higher [Coronary Heart Disease] risk than lean people,” Lassale discovered. “These findings challenge the concept of ‘metabolically healthy obesity’, encouraging population-wide strategies to tackle obesity.”

    Follow the author of this article on Twitter: @Toni_Airaksinen





    Toni Airaksinen

    Toni Airaksinen

    New York Campus Correspondent

    Toni Airaksinen is a New York Campus Correspondent, and reports liberal bias and abuse on college campuses for Campus Reform. She is a junior at Barnard College, and also contributes regularly to The College Fix, USA Today College, Red Alert Politics, and Quillette Magazine. She formerly held a post with the Columbia Spectator and has been featured on Fox News and on the Drudge Report.

    More By Toni Airaksinen

    Latest 20 Articles