Yale student asks Buckley Program to honor Chelsea Manning

Toni Airaksinen
New York Campus Correspondent

  • A Yale University student recently proposed inviting Chelsea Manning to the annual "Disinvitation Dinner" held by the William F. Buckley, Jr. Program to honor speakers who have had speaking events cancelled.
  • Aaron Sibarium argues that inviting Manning would show that "intellectual diversity is nonpartisan" after the last two dinners honored conservatives, but the director of the program flatly refused to invite Manning to any future event.
  • Chelsea Manning's defiant tweet after Harvard rescinded an invitation for her to serve as a visiting fellow.

    A student at Yale University recently called upon the William F. Buckley Jr. Program to extend an invitation to Chelsea Manning for its upcoming “Disinvitation Dinner.”

    The program hosts an annual Disinvitation Dinner, during which a speaker who was previously disinvited from another university is honored and gives a speech to the campus community.

    "The left should care about intellectual diversity, too."   

    [RELATED: Va. Tech re-invites disinvited conservative speaker]

    Citing Manning’s recent disinvitation from a fellowship at the Harvard Kennedy School, Yale senior Aaron Sibarium suggests in a column for The Yale Daily News that inviting Manning would be an excellent way to show that “intellectual diversity is nonpartisan.”  

    “What better way to stand on principle—and above politics—than to invite Chelsea Manning to the dinner? Her presence would send a clear message that intellectual diversity is nonpartisan,” Sibarium writes, adding that it “would shatter Buckley’s reputation as a front for campus conservatism, elevating the program to an unassailable moral high ground.”

    Doing so “would make Yale the free speech capital of the Ivy League,” he argues, noting that it would also “drive Harvard crazy.”

    Sibarium, a student fellow with the Buckley Program, told Campus Reform that inviting Manning to speak would help to counter the culture of disinvitations, a growing phenomenon that Sibarium finds especially troubling.

    [RELATED: Yale among recipients of infamous ‘muzzle’ award]

    There have been at least 11 disinvitation attempts in 2017 so far, according to the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE), including political scientist Charles Murray, commentator Ben Shapiro, Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos, the Dalai Lama, and U.S. Senator John Cornyn (R-Texas).

    Regardless of a speaker's politics, Sibarium believes that the practice of cancelling controversial speakers should be opposed.

    “There's always going to be someone who objects to the speaker you invite,” he told Campus Reform. “I oppose the heckler's veto under all circumstances.”

    Sibarium, a strong supporter of free speech, worries that disinvitations have a negative impact on the exchange of ideas on college campuses, pointing out that "if we start making judgments about which ideas are beyond the pale, and we get those judgments wrong, we could miss out on the right ideas."

    Indeed, he said his suggestion has nothing to do with Manning, personally, but rather was conceived out of a basic desire to stand up for the principle of free expression.

    “Really, I don't like Chelsea Manning. I doubt she has anything good to contribute,” he noted. “But the problem is if you allow someone to say that Manning doesn't have anything to contribute, therefore she's disinvited, well someone could make the same claim about Charles Murray. It sets a precedent.”

    [RELATED: Half of college students feel intimidated when sharing opinions]

    Each of the last two Disinvitation Dinners hosted by the Buckley Program honored conservatives: Raymond Kelly, a former NYC Police Commissioner, and George F. Will, a well-known conservative commentator, and Sibarium believes that inviting Manning would help to counter the notion that conservative concerns about intellectual diversity only apply to like-minded individuals.

    "If only people you invite to the dinner are on the political right, it makes it look as if intellectual diversity is something that only the right cares about,” he explained. “The left should care about intellectual diversity, too.”

    Campus Reform reached out to Lauren Nobel, the Founder of the Buckley Program, who stated that the next speaker for the Disinvitation Dinner has already been decided.

    When asked whether the Buckley Program would consider honoring Manning at a future dinner, or at any future events, Nobel replied, “no.”

    Follow the author of this article on Twitter: @Toni_Airaksinen





    Toni Airaksinen

    Toni Airaksinen

    New York Campus Correspondent
    Toni Airaksinen is a New York Campus Correspondent, where she reports on free speech issues and social justice research. She is a senior at Barnard College, majoring in Urban Studies and Environmental Science. She is also a columnist for PJ Media, and formerly held a post with USA TODAY College, The Columbia Spectator, and Quillette.
    More By Toni Airaksinen

    Latest 20 Articles